Runningstream, you make a good case for never reading art criticism, or for never using any of those opinions as reasons to like or dislike someone's work. And normally, I wouldn't even bring the criticism up, but it seems to have been some sort of legacy in the Wyeth line to be brutalized by the critics.
I confess that I didn't care much for Jamie Wyeth's portraitures of some famous people, even his portrait of JFKennedy, but his animals have a light in them, and I have no qualms about saying I love his critters.
Andrew Wyeth is stark almost to the point of being bizarre, but I really love those paintings posted in his section.
NC Wyeth deserves a lot of sympathy, in my opinion. His was a case of choosing to support his family.